How to Get Local Online Shoppers to Visit In-Store for the First Time
Local online shoppers are a huge opportunity for your stores, but how do you coax them off the couch and into your aisles?

So you’ve got an online retail presence that’s hotter than a new Kendrick album release—congratulations! In 2025, an influential web shop can be a major flex, fueling your brand’s reputation and reeling in ecommerce revenue. But here’s the thing: relying solely on online sales can sometimes leave your brand feeling about as impersonal as a chat with a bot. When a customer has never stepped foot inside your store, you’re missing out on one of the best ways to build loyalty: face-to-face interaction. There’s something about meeting IRL—like seeing Kendrick live instead of just listening on Spotify—that makes the experience more memorable.
Brick-and-mortar shops aren’t going extinct any time soon. In fact, in recent years many savvy retailers have double downed on the in-store experiences to build stronger bonds to great success. In late 2024, monthly retail visits increased by nearly 10% compared to five years ago.
This is because in-store visits are good for both the brand and the customer. It allows for that clienteling touch, the upsell, and the sense of belonging that a pixelated shopping cart icon simply can’t match. A physical presence lets you show off your brand vibe in real-time: the layout, the scent of fresh products (and candles, perhaps?), the curated playlists, and the warm, genuine smiles from your staff—these details can evoke loyalty that’s way harder to replicate in an online setting.
So how do you coax those online shoppers, some of whom might not even realize how close they live to your store, off their couches and into your aisles?
1. The Grand Quest: Converting Online Shoppers Into In-Store Guests
Think of the modern shopper as someone with an array of streaming services at their fingertips: they’re spoiled for choice. Clicking “buy” from the comfort of pajamas while rewatching The Office can be more convenient than venturing out into the mean streets of real life. Plus, it’s 2025 so it’s not that uncommon to see delivery drones might be zipping around dropping packages on doorsteps quicker than you can say, “Alexa, what’s my next order’s ETA?”
However, when a customer hasn’t visited you in person, they’re missing out on all the intangibles that make shopping an experience rather than a mere transaction. Sure, they can flick through your website. But a physical store? That’s your brand’s playground—where you can showcase colors, music, scents, and staff personalities that reflect who you are at heart.
Why the In-Store Visit Matters
- Deeper Loyalty: When a shopper physically interacts with your brand, they’re more likely to form that emotional connection. After all, how many times have you gone back to a local coffee shop just because the barista there remembered your name?
- Higher Conversion Rates: Research shows in-store conversion rates range from 20-40% compared to just 1-3% for ecommerce. That means getting a customer to visit your physical location is potentially 10 times more valuable than having them browse your website—making every in-store visit a golden opportunity.
- Upselling & Cross-Selling: While your e-commerce site might be great at suggesting “you may also like” products, nothing beats a real person who can read your body language and say, “We’ve got a matching scarf that would look perfect with that coat you just picked out.”
- Personal Relationships: Face-to-face contact builds trust. Customers get to chat with sales associates, ask questions, and get immediate feedback. This can turn a casual buyer into a brand evangelist.
- Community Building: Having a physical store makes you part of a neighborhood. You can host events, be part of local happenings, and become that “go-to place” for a curated, personalized shopping experience.
Now, if this all sounds like the beginning of a hero’s journey, that’s because it is! Though we call it the “customer journey,” of course. And your mission is to guide your local online customers from their comfy living rooms to the bustling heart of your store.
2. Strategies for Luring Local E-Shoppers Into Your Store
So how can your brand entice more local online shoppers to visit your stores for the first time? Let’s break down the essential tactics:
Identify Local Shoppers in Your CRM
CRM segmentation is like the sorting hat in Harry Potter: it groups your customers into categories so you can better target them. In this case, you’re looking for the “Gryffindor” (or “Slytherin,” we don’t judge) of local shoppers—people who live within, say, a 5-mile radius of your store. This is the group to hone in on with specialized messages.
Step-by-Step:
- Run a Location Filter: Pull data from your CRM on who lives within a certain zip code or geographic radius.
- Check Past Purchases: See if they’ve bought from you recently online, or if it’s been a while.
- Create Segmented Lists: Label them “Local but has never visited store” or “Frequent online shopper near our location.”
- Targeted Messaging: Craft communications that speak to these folks differently than your out-of-state crowd. You’ll highlight in-store benefits and possibly mention local landmarks or weather conditions (like, “Our store is the perfect place to cool down on these scorching summer days!”).
By knowing exactly who’s in your neighborhood, you can personalize emails or texts along the lines of “Hey neighbor, we’re practically around the corner—why not pop in for a real-life brand experience?” This type of outreach feels more like a friendly invitation than a generic marketing pitch.
Offer In-Store-Only Promotions
Everyone loves a deal, but even more love an exclusive & personal one. Brands that offer special access, VIP treatment, and a sense of belonging win at customer loyalty. And if your audience can only redeem a certain deal by physically stepping into your store, they might just decide the discount is worth putting on real pants and leaving the house.
Possible In-Store-Only Deals:
- Flash Sale: Announce a 10% discount that’s only valid in-store. (“Come see us this Saturday between 12 and 4 PM for a flash sale on our new arrivals!”)
- Bundle Offers: If they’ve previously bought a jacket online, offer them a discount on matching accessories, but only if they pop in to pick them up.
- Limited Edition Products: Release a small run of products that can’t be purchased online. This fosters a sense of urgency and exclusivity.
Execution Tips:
- Let them know it’s a “one-time” or “limited-time” offer.
- Mention how they’ll save on shipping fees if they purchase in-store.
- Entice them with local perks: “Try it on in person! No returns needed, no guesswork with sizing!”
The FOMO factor can be incredibly motivating. If they know a deal is short-lived and location-specific, they’re more likely to check out your brick & mortar locations. You can highlight these promotions in both emails and SMS, leaning on your CRM’s ability to personalize the message with their name, past purchase, or brand interest.
Offer In-Store Styling Appointments With Their Favorite Sales Rep
Shoppers generally enjoy having someone who knows their style, body type, and preferences. Someone they trust who can transform a quick “maybe I’ll check it out” visit into a day of indulgent self-care. If you have a star salesperson who has built relationships via chat or email, let your CRM reveal which customers vibed well with that particular associate. Then, extend a personal invite: “Book a styling session with Sarah—she loved helping you choose that cocktail dress last month, and she can’t wait to show you our new collection in person.”
Leverage Appointment Booking:
- Personalized Preparation: When a customer books an appointment, your associate can pull items in advance based on their purchase history and preferences, creating a customized shopping experience that feels exclusive and thoughtful.
- Dedicated Attention: In-store appointments guarantee one-on-one time with a knowledgeable associate, something that casual walk-ins can't always count on during busy shopping days.
- Calendar Integration: Make booking seamless with an online calendar link. Let them pick the date and time so it feels on their terms, not forced.
Be sure to use your appointment booking link on well-trafficked pages on your site, such as on your store locator page (to pull in those locals). Likewise, arm your live chat reps (or your chatbots) with booking links to grab visitors when they’re already in the mindset of engaging with your brand.
Also, consider sweetening the deal with an added bonus: “Book an in-store styling appointment, and receive a complimentary accessory or 10% off your total purchase.” The goal is to make them feel special, like they’re on the VIP list for a secret concert.
Create Exclusive In-Store Experiences
Let’s face it, we’re living in the era of experiences. Whether it’s an influencer-hosted runway show or a cooking class in the back of a high-end culinary store, experiences equal engagement. If you’re hosting events that are only accessible in-store, you tap into the age-old human curiosity and that desire to be part of something cool.
Event Ideas:
- Influencer Takeover: Invite a popular local influencer or style expert to your store for a meet-and-greet, mini fashion show, or Q&A. Advertise the event to your local CRM list.
- Mixer or Party: Wine, cheese, maybe even a live DJ spinning your brand’s vibe. People always love free refreshments and a place to mingle.
- Loyalty Program Bash: Reward your top customers with an exclusive after-hours shopping event, or an early VIP preview of your newest line. They get the first crack at new items before they hit the racks.
By providing a social, festive atmosphere, you transform the typical “store visit” into a mini-adventure. People will want to document it, share it on social media, and talk about it to their friends, which is marketing gold. Plus, by limiting admission to local folks or loyalty program members, you add that elusive “OMG, I’m on the guest list” feeling.
Offer Buy Online Pickup In Store (BOPIS)
BOPIS isn’t just a fun acronym to say—it’s also a powerful tool to unite your online and offline realms. Studies have shown that many consumers opt for BOPIS in recent years when it’s available because it saves shipping costs and ensures they can get their item faster (not to mention the instant gratification of not having to wait for a mail carrier).
How to Make BOPIS Irresistible:
- Highlight the Savings: “Skip shipping fees, pick up at our store!”
- Speedy Retrieval: Promise that the order will be ready for pickup within a certain number of hours. If your staff is quick, highlight that efficiency.
- In-Store Perks: Offer a small incentive for them to browse once they’re in: “Come pick up your package and enjoy 5% off anything else you buy in-store that day!”
- Flawless Execution: Nothing kills a BOPIS program like having the order not be ready or staff unable to find the package. Make sure your team is well-trained, signage is clear, and the process is swift and friendly.
Once they arrive, you can gently steer them toward a new collection or a stylish display. People often end up buying more items once they’re already there. It’s like every visit to Target, no?
3. Endear’s Proven Engagement Recipe
If you’re thinking, “These strategies sound great, but how do I time them effectively without becoming that clingy brand that’s always in my inbox/texts?” don’t worry, we’ve got you covered. Endear has a step-by-step approach to keep your outreach structured and unobtrusive. After all, we want to be the charming dinner guest, not the unwelcome houseguest who never leaves.
1. Intro Email 7 Days After an Online Purchase
The Why:
- The customer is still in the honeymoon phase of their purchase. They’re excited about the items they received, or they might be anxiously tracking the package.
- This is the perfect time to introduce them to your store location without being overbearing.
The Content:
- Thank them for their purchase (politeness always wins) and let them know they have a direct line to reach you with any questions they might have
- Mention, “Did you know we have a local store near you in [City Name]? We’d love for you to visit us and see our latest collection in person!”
- Provide a small incentive or highlight an upcoming in-store event.
Keep it short, sweet, and friendly.
2. Fit Check-In at the 3-Week Mark
The Why:
- About three weeks after purchase, they’ve had enough time to try the product, break it in, or realize if there’s an issue with sizing or style.
- It’s prime time to show you care about their satisfaction.
The Content:
- Ask them how the product is fitting, if there are any concerns or questions.
- “Need a size exchange? Want to see coordinating pieces? Our local store team is here to help, and we’d love to see you!”
- Direct them to book an appointment or simply drop by.
This message leans heavily on the personal connection angle. It’s your way of saying, “We don’t just want your money. We genuinely want you to be happy with your purchase.”
3. At 2 Months, Invite Them to a Personal IRL Styling Appointment
The Why:
- Two months in, they’re likely either fully in love with their purchase or maybe they’ve only worn it once. Either way, this is a chance to expand their wardrobe or see new arrivals.
- If they’re local, they may have been thinking about “checking out the store someday.” Now’s your chance to give them that extra nudge.
The Content:
- “We loved helping you find [Product Name] back in [Month]. Why not come in for a personal styling appointment? We’ll pull together some pieces just for you!”
- Let them know about the exclusive discount or styling perk they get if they show up.
- Use your CRM data to send the message from the sales rep they already connected with online.
When you personalize this invite—mentioning their previous purchase, the staff member they spoke with, or their style preferences—it shows you’re paying attention, not just spamming generic promotions.
4. At 4 Months, Invite Them to a Store Event
The Why:
- Four months is enough time for another gentle touchpoint. If they haven’t come in yet, maybe they need a social event or a fresh reason to see the store.
- Perhaps your store has new inventory, or you’re hosting a special gathering (remember those exclusive experiences?).
The Content:
- Invite them to a trunk show, a style workshop, or a party featuring local artists or musicians.
- Mention any freebies or special elements: “Complimentary cocktails,” “Meet the designer,” or “Exclusive preview night.”
- Tie it back to your brand identity: If you’re eco-friendly, host a sustainability workshop. If you’re big on local culture, bring in a local band.
Emphasize that being there in person is half the fun. People crave experiences, and if they like your brand, they’ll likely be intrigued to see what a real-life event is like.
5. If Still No Purchase, Consider Them Online-Only Shoppers After 6–8 Months (Until Their Next Online Order)
The Why:
- Sometimes, people just prefer online shopping for various reasons: convenience, distance, or personal preference.
- If by 6–8 months they’ve shown zero interest in stepping through your doors, it might be time to place them in the “online-only” bucket—at least until they place another order.
The Content:
- You can still send them occasional store-related promotions, but you might pivot to highlighting online exclusives or deals that align with their known behavior.
- Focus on re-activating them via their typical channel. If they do place another online order, you can try again to bring them in-store with a fresh approach.
Don’t view this as a loss. The beauty of a CRM is that once new data comes in (like a fresh purchase or new interest signals), you can adapt the customer journey once again.
4. Bringing Online Shoppers In-Store as KPI
Bringing your local online shoppers into a physical store for the first time requires a strategic approach. You can’t just spam them with “Come see us!” without offering a reason, a benefit, or a spark of excitement that convinces them to ditch the slippers and step outside. And for the best sales & marketing teams in retail, converting online shoppers to in-store shoppers can be a useful key performance indicator of the team’s clienteling effectiveness.
By leveraging your CRM, you gain the ability to segment local addresses, craft personal communications, and systematically invite shoppers to special promotions and events. The key is to strike that balance: you want to be present in their mind, but not so pushy that you get shoved in the spam folder faster than a 90’s chain email. Whether it’s in-store-exclusive discounts, curated styling sessions, or BOPIS that eliminates shipping hassles, every tactic aims to show them, “Hey, we’re worth the trip!”
Ultimately, physical stores offer something the online world can’t fully replicate: genuine human connection, tangibility, and ambiance. When people walk into your space, they get a sense of your brand’s soul—something that digital images and product descriptions can only partially convey. For many, that personal touch is what transforms a one-off purchase into ongoing loyalty.